Overview
Course description: This course has multiple components and targets graduate (PhD) students. First, it introduces students to the principles of conducting research in computer science, including tips on reading and reviewing papers, developing and debating ideas, conducting research, research integrity, and writing and presenting one's work. Second, it provides an opportunity for students to work through the sections of a complete paper, including getting feedback on their writing from the instructor and peers, adjusting the paper based on this feedback, and receiving further feedback. Third, it asks students to present recent papers in their field, and receive feedback on these presentations. Fourth, it introduces students to some of the ongoing research in the department.Prerequisites: None, but note course only counts for the PhD program.
Canvas: We will use it for assignment turn-in and announcements.
[top]
Policies
Grading
Grading will be based on the following components:- Participation in discussions, feedback to peers, questions asked: 20%
- Paper section drafts, offering feedback, revisions, writing and responding to review: 20%
- Critical paper presentation: 10%
- Literature review presentation: 10%
- Annotated bibliography: 10%
- Idea pitch: 10%
- Paper pair presentation: 10%
- Project presentation: 10%
Collaboration Policy and Academic Honesty
You will do your work individually, unless otherwise stated. You will not use AI to help with writing. You may use AI to help with finding relevant papers for your research (i.e. using AI as a search engine). You will always cite your sources, for any materials you use. When in doubt about what you can or cannot use, ask the instructor. A first offense will cause you to get 0% credit on the assignment. A report will be filed with the school. A second offense will cause you to fail the class and receive disciplinary penalty. Please consult SCI's Academic Integrity Policy. Also make sure you are familiar with the concept of plagiarism.Note on Disabilities
If you have a disability for which you are or may be requesting an accommodation, you are encouraged to contact both your instructor and Disability Resources and Services (DRS), 140 William Pitt Union, (412) 648-7890, drsrecep@pitt.edu, (412) 228-5347 for P3 ASL users, as early as possible in the term. DRS will verify your disability and determine reasonable accommodations for this course.Note on Medical Conditions
If you have a medical condition which will prevent you from doing a certain assignment, you must inform the instructor of this before the deadline. You must then submit documentation of your condition within a week of the assignment deadline.Statement on Classroom Recording
To ensure the free and open discussion of ideas, students may not record classroom lectures, discussion and/or activities without the advance written permission of the instructor, and any such recording properly approved in advance can be used solely for the student's own private use.[top]
Schedule
Date | Topics (slides) | In-class work and homework | |
Aug 26-28 | Intros, course structure, PhD at Pitt, research integrity (pdf) | lecture and discussion | |
Sept 2-4 | Reading and reviewing papers; conferences; ideas (pdf) | lecture and discussion | |
Sept 9-11 | Writing up and presenting your work (pdf) | lecture and discussion | |
Sept 16-18 | Present one critical & recent paper (and feedback) | 10-min presentation (HW), 5-min feedback |
|
Sept 23-25 | Literature reviews (and feedback) | 10-min presentation (HW), 5-min feedback |
|
Sept 30-Oct 2 | Senior grad student talks and Q & A | HW: annotated bibliography (notes on 30 papers, Canvas) |
|
Oct 7-9 | Pitch and debate project ideas | 10-min presentation (HW), 5-min feedback |
|
Oct 14-16 | Intro and related work section; feedback and revision | each class: 20-min read peer's draft (HW), 20-min feedback (w/ peer, instructor), 30-min revise |
|
Oct 21-23 | Pitt faculty talks | mini talks and discussion | |
Oct 28-30 | Paper pair comparisons | 10-min compare/contrast presentation, 5-min discussion | |
Nov 4-6 | Method section (and figures); feedback and revision | each class: 20-min read peer's draft (HW), 20-min feedback (w/ peer, instructor), 30-min revise |
|
Nov 11-13 | Method and implementation challenges; breakouts with senior grad students |
1st class: 2x30-min breakouts, 2nd class: 6-min presentation of next steps | |
Nov 18-20 | Results section (and figures); feedback and revision | each class: 20-min read peer's draft (HW), 20-min feedback (w/ peer, instructor), 30-min revise |
|
Nov 25-27 | No class (Thanksgiving) | ||
Dec 2-4 | Write reviews and rebuttals | HW: complete papers; 1st class: read peer's paper and write review; 2nd class: draft response, discuss w/ reviewer |
|
Dec 9-11 | Project presentations (and feedback) | 10-min presentation (HW), 5-min feedback |
[top]
Readings
Integrity:- On Being a Scientist: Responsible Conduct in Research
- Honor in Science
- Guidelines for Responsible Conduct of Research (Pitt)
- Guide to CS PhD students at Pitt
- Keshav, How to Read a Paper, ACM SIGCOMM Computer Communication Review 37(3): 83-84, July 2007.
- Hanson and McNamee, Efficient Reading of Papers in Science and Technology
- Fong, How to Read a CS Research Paper, July 2004.
- Griswold, How to Read an Engineering Research Paper
- Griswold's paper comprehension template
- Hill and McKinley, Notes on Constructive and Positive Reviewing, May 2005.
- Smith, The Task of the Referee, IEEE Computer 23(4), April 1990.
- Roscoe, Writing reviews for systems conferences, March 2007.
- Belongie, Paper gestalt
- Huang, Deep paper gestalt
- Gao et al., Does my Rebuttal Matter?
- Su and Crandall, The Affective Growth of Computer Vision
- Real ML reviews: 1, 2, 3, 4
- Raskar, How to Invent
- Strunk and White, The Elements of Style
- Jones, How to write a great research paper
- Knuth, Mathematical Writing
- Freeman, How to write a good research paper
- Hertzman, Writing Research Papers
- Parikh et al., How we write rebuttals
- Ernst, Giving a technical presentation
- Shewchuk, Giving an Academic Talk
- Van Loan, The Short Talk