Journal of Visual Languages and Computing


Review Form


Please return review by e-mail to:
Dr. S. K. Chang, Dept. of Computer Science
University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15260
(Tel: 412-624-8423, Fax: 412-624-8465, e-mail: chang@cs.pitt.edu)

Paper Title: [TITLE]

Paper Authors: [AUTHOR]

Paper Id: [NO]

Reviewer Id: [ID]

( ) I have forwarded this paper to another reviewer (name and address):



Summary of Evaluation:

( ) Excellent ( ) Good ( ) Fair ( ) Poor

Subject matter: ( ) highly relevant ( ) relevant ( ) somewhat relevant

Technical content: ( ) correct ( ) appears to be correct ( ) contains errors (please give details below)

English: ( ) no improvement necessary ( ) could be improved ( ) must be improved ( ) unacceptable

Recommendation:

( ) Accept with no changes

( ) Accept if certain minor revisions are made (see below)

( ) Author should prepare a major revision and resubmit paper (see below)

( ) Submit to the following journal: ___________________________________

( ) Reject (see below for reasons)

Detailed comments for revision, or reasons for rejection (please attach additional pages if necessary):